Benefit Cap – a real example of Arbeit macht frei

The BBC local news covered a story about “John” (not his real name) from Wirral in Merseyside who has had a Benefit Cap letter from the DWP


The above is the letter or a screenshot of it from the BBC North West Tonight article that you can watch here – 40 seconds of misery – and a cut of £70.63 per week to his housing benefit which is £306.90 per calendar month.

Could you find £306.90 per month to pay your mortgage in order to keep a roof over your head and that of your children?  This is what “John” will have to do – an do from his subsistence level social security benefits!

Get a job says the government.  You only have to work 16 hours per week to qualify for working tax credit and thus be exempt from the benefit cap.  That’s correct.

Yet if “John” did work 16 hours per week at £7.20 per hour he would be better off by £22.73 per week – assuming he has no travel to work or any other work associated costs.  That £22.73 better off in work for 16 hours includes the £115.20 he would pick up in wages so in reality he would be working for the princely sum of £1.49 per hour.

Those figures above are from a benefit calculator and one of any available online and that is the situation if “John” had to pay child care costs of £300 per week – which for 4 children at 16 hours each ain’t going to happen – and for which “John” would get back £210 per week – or a net cost of £90 per week which is rather a lot out of wages of £115.20 per week!

If “John” did not need child care he would be much better off as he would only lose £12.74 per week in overall benefit and with his wage of £115.20 per week that leaves him £102.46 per week better off in overall terms.

So “John” the government position is work for £1.49 per hour or the kids lose the roof over their heads!  What a nice caring government we have!!


“John” leave the kids at home and don’t have any childcare costs and you will be £102.46 per week better off for working 16 hours (less any travel to or other work costs) and have a roof over the kids head.

Given that the DWP say ‘reasonable’ travel to work time is 90 minutes each way and every JobCentre has a map showing the travel to work areas, then ‘reasonable’ travel to work costs can easily exceed £15 per day and of course also ups the child care needed by three hours per day too.

So four days at four hours work becomes four days at 7 hours child care for four children which is 112 hours of childcare per week!

That would be the child care that “John” could not afford even if he got a job in the next street an is not available in any case

Good luck “John!” Work will set you free say the DWP!

work-will-set-you-free work-will-set-you-free work-will-set-you-free


If you do watch the 40 second video please make sure after reading the facts above that you read the really really caring comments underneath the video!!

It seems those who guarded the place where they passed the Arbeit Macht Frei sign every day are now all living in the North West!!

8 thoughts on “Benefit Cap – a real example of Arbeit macht frei

  1. It’s our DICK HEADED Governments that first gave landlords and homeowners the opportunity to increase their rents to the amount they wanted and now they are doing a BENEFITS CAP. If anyone is kicked out of their properties or made homeless because they are unable to pay their rents, it’s our Governments fault.

Please leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s